This shawl looks like it stepped straight out of great grandma's closet, which is a good thing. If you're looking for an authentic crocheted shawl for reenactments or costumes, this is perfect. If you're looking for a mid-weight shawl to wear to church or around the house, this could also work. It's elegant, but definitely not modern. On a young girl, it looks very trendy and throwback. It could look dowdy if worn with an old fashioned dress, but with something more modern or slacks or jeans, it's absolutely adorable.I love…— the quality of the crochet is very good. The yarn is soft but functional, warm, but not blanket-thick.— the style is very antiquated, which is the look I'm going for.You won't like this if…— you want something that looks modern. This truly looks authentically old. I LOVE it, but you might not.